Forget Edward vs Jacob
I have a problem.
No, I don’t consider my Twilight obsession a problem, thank you very much. It’s more of a boy problem. I’m caught in a triangle between two men. Now, it’s not what you think, because neither of them know I exist, but still. I like to consider myself a one man type of gal. But, alas, I just can’t decide.
Just who is my top guy, Robert Pattinson or Jackson Rathbone?
Really, they’re crazy similar, right down to the fact that Jackson, who plays Jasper Hale in case you didn’t know, was Catherine Hardwick’s second choice for the role of Edward Cullen.
Point of interest – that means Kristen Stewart has kissed both of my guys. Jealous!
Anyway. Let’s talk about all the things I love about Rob and Jackson to see who comes out on top (that’s what she said).

The Hair
Rob: Who doesn’t know about Rob’s hair? I mean – it doesn’t matter what he does to it. Since he’s always running his fingers through it (and let us not talk about Rob’s fingers because I could stare at those for days), it constantly looks like sex hair.
Jackson: This boy is always playing with his hair but unlike Rob – for whom it’s a nervous tick – Jackson uses it as another extension of his eclectic style. When he had an odd cut while he was doing The Last Airbender he spiked it up into an insanely high mohawk.
Verdict: Tie – Whatever length, unkempt or slicked back, these boys do not know how to have a bad hair day. It’s ridiculous.

The Smile
Rob: Do you know what I love about Rob? He giggles. It’s utterly adorable. He smiles with his entire face. I love his grin. It was one of the best things about Eclipse – he actually got to use that gorgeous smile of his more.
Jackson: Oh, lord. This boy has the kind of smile where, were he to flash it at you, you would instantly do whatever he asked. What’s that Jackson? You want me to kill the president? Well, yessir. Coming right up. And on top of it, he does this little lip purse. You see it in Eclipse when he’s facing Emmett during training – “Don’t hold back.”
Verdict: Tie – Rob’s grin or Jackson’s lip purse. I just cannot decide.
The Accent
Rob : British. I could listen to him say bouffant, coccyx and nachos all fucking day long tyvm.
Jackson: Texas Twang. Low and deep and just beautiful. Don’t believe me? Try watching him live. Every time he speaks – I swoon.
The Music
Rob: Now, generally speaking I am not actually attracted to Edward…unless he’s on that piano. That. Scene. Was. Hot. On top of his extraordinary piano skills, Rob, of course, contributed two songs to the Twilight soundtrack (voice: low, gravely, wonderful) and also wrote the guitar music, which he played, for Never Think.
Jackson: With his band, 100 Monkeys, I’ve seen Jackson play guitar, bass, keyboard, drums, trumpet, electric ukulele and harmonica and sing. All in one night. Good lord. ::fans self::
Verdict: Tie – They’re both insanely talented with their instruments (that’s what she said).
The Acting
Rob: Okay – first of all, I agree with his choices as Edward but, that being said, Twilight is just not the kind of movie you want to judge an actor on. Rob is amazing in that he tends to choose scripts that are very character driven. He’s amazing. He disappears into his roles completely. I’m sorry – if you can make me forget you’re 1) Edward Cullen and 2) Robert Pattinson – you are talented. Loved him as a nerd in Bad Mother’s Handbook, loved him as Salvador Dali in Little Ashes (PS – the boy makes kissing look HOT, man or woman), and Remember Me? Good lord. Powerful.
Jackson: Now – when I first saw Jackson it was in interviews and I didn’t know what to make of him. I mean, really, you cannot judge a good actor based off of a look of agony and “Oh, I think we can handle that.” Then I sat down to watch Criminal Minds. Holy. Crap. Y’all. If you have not seen Jackson’s episode of Criminal Minds: Conflicted, watch it. It’s stunning. Just. Stunning. I was literally staring at him gape mouthed. And thus…my Jackson Rathbone obsession began.
Verdict: Rob has a slight edge only because his roles are so character driven and accessible. Jackson tends to choose…odd roles. He’s utterly fantastic, but they’re hard to re-watch (especially Dread. OGOD DON’T MAKE ME RELIVE THE END OF DREAD).
Accessibility
Rob: Ha. The poor boy is mobbed everywhere he goes. Good luck with that.
Jackson: If you’re anywhere on the 100 Monkeys’ touring schedule, Jackson is easy access (that’s what she said). I’ve seen the boy five times in concert and talked to him once – and I’m pretty shy about these things. Most people who go to a 100 Monkeys concert can easily get a handshake, maybe an autograph and possibly a picture. Either way – you can get close to him. And believe me. You want to. He is utterly gorgeous up front and his entire band is talented. It’s a fun show no matter who you are. And Jackson has this way of engaging the audience. If you’re close enough – he will look directly AT you for a moment while he’s singing. And that my friends…that is… just… ungh.
Verdict: Jackson by a long shot.
Winner
None. Well, crap that didn’t help me any. Sigh. I suppose I will have to keep on admiring both of them.
Poor, poor me.
All Robert Pattinson images were gathered from edwardandbella.net and all Jackson Rathbone images were gathered from ifelthope.net unless otherwise noted.
Gratuitous Rob/Jackson action. Jackson interviews Rob – hilarity ensues:
Posted in Fandom, Stars of Twilight having 6 comments »





